Despite the potential concerns of many patients, extensive research and evidence have consistently demonstrated that dental amalgam fillings are COMPLETELY SAFE for use in dental restorations. Numerous studies and regulatory assessments have concluded that no confirmed evidence links the mercury in dental amalgam to any disease or toxic effect. Even when amalgam restorations are removed, the levels of mercury released are not associated with any adverse health effects. This comprehensive analysis aims to address any concerns between dental amalgam fillings and mercury poisoning, explain why some people are worried, clarify what mercury poisoning is, and ultimately provide reassurance based on scientific evidence that dental amalgam fillings are safe.
Understanding the Concerns About Mercury in Amalgam Fillings
Historical Context and Public Perception
The controversy surrounding dental amalgam fillings primarily stems from the fact that they contain mercury, a metal known for its toxicity in certain forms and doses. Dental amalgam, which has been used for over 150 years, is a mixture of mercury, silver, tin, and copper. The presence of mercury, which makes up about 50% of the mixture, has led to fears about potential mercury poisoning.
Public concern increased significantly in the late 20th century when the adverse health effects of mercury became more widely understood.
Mercury poisoning occurs when a person is exposed to high levels of mercury, which can damage the nervous, digestive, and immune systems, and can be fatal in severe cases. There are three primary forms of mercury:
- Elemental Mercury: This is the form used in dental amalgam. It is liquid at room temperature and can vaporize into mercury vapor, which can be inhaled.
- Inorganic Mercury Compounds: These are often found in batteries and some industrial processes.
- Organic Mercury Compounds (Methylmercury): These are found in certain fish and shellfish and are highly toxic.
Symptoms of mercury poisoning vary depending on the type and level of exposure but can include tremors, insomnia, memory loss, neuromuscular effects, headaches, and cognitive and motor dysfunction.
Why Mercury Poisoning is Not an Issue with Amalgam Fillings
Extensive Research and Regulatory Review
Multiple studies over several decades have evaluated the safety of dental amalgam. These studies have included both laboratory research and large-scale epidemiological studies involving thousands of patients. Regulatory agencies, including the World Health Organization (WHO) and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) have all conducted comprehensive reviews of the available data.
The consensus from these reviews is clear: dental amalgam is a safe and effective material for dental restorations. The mercury in amalgam is bound within the alloy, and only very small amounts of mercury vapor are released during chewing. These amounts are well below the threshold considered to be harmful.
Biological Monitoring and Health Outcomes
One of the most significant studies is the New England Children’s Amalgam Trial, which followed hundreds of children with amalgam fillings over a span of seven years. The study found no statistically significant differences in neuropsychological or renal function between children with amalgam fillings and those with composite fillings.
Moreover, biological monitoring of patients with amalgam fillings has consistently shown that the levels of mercury in blood and urine are within safe limits. These findings are supported by research indicating that even the removal of amalgam fillings does not lead to toxic levels of mercury exposure. The process of removing fillings can temporarily increase mercury vapor levels, but these levels quickly return to normal and are not linked to any long-term health effects.
Can Mercury Fillings Be Removed?
Removing dental amalgam fillings is a procedure that some patients may choose due to concerns about mercury exposure or for aesthetic reasons. The process of removal involves the careful drilling out of the existing amalgam and replacing it with an alternative restorative material such as composite resin, porcelain, or gold.
In general, if your filling is in good condition and your dentist or healthcare professional finds no decay beneath it, removal of the amalgam filling is not recommended. Removing intact amalgam fillings can lead to the unnecessary loss of healthy tooth structure and may temporarily increase exposure to mercury vapor during the removal process. Some of the few situations where it may be required include:
- Deterioration or Damage to the Filling:
- Wear and Tear: Over time, amalgam fillings can deteriorate due to constant chewing and grinding, leading to cracks or breaks.
- Leaking Fillings: If the seal between the tooth and the filling breaks down, bacteria can enter, causing decay under the filling.
- Tooth Decay or Structural Issues:
- New Decay: If new decay develops around or under the filling, removal may be necessary to properly treat the tooth.
- Tooth Fractures: Large amalgam fillings can sometimes contribute to the fracture of the remaining tooth structure, necessitating removal and repair.
- Aesthetic Concerns:
- Appearance: Some patients prefer the appearance of tooth-colored composite fillings over the metallic look of amalgam fillings and choose to replace them for cosmetic reasons.
- Allergies and Sensitivities:
- Mercury Allergy: Although rare, some individuals may have a confirmed allergy or sensitivity to mercury or other metals in amalgam.
- Symptoms of Sensitivity: In such cases, symptoms might include oral lesions or other allergic reactions, and removal may be necessary.
In the case where dental fillings do need to be removed, dental professionals employ several safety measures to minimize exposure to both patients and dental staff. These protocols include:
- High-Volume Suction: A high-volume suction device is used to capture mercury vapor and amalgam particles directly at the source, reducing the amount that can be inhaled.
- Rubber Dam Isolation: A rubber dam can be placed around the tooth to isolate it from the rest of the mouth. This barrier helps to prevent amalgam particles from being swallowed or coming into contact with other oral tissues.
Summarizing the Evidence on Dental Amalgam Safety
The debate over dental amalgam fillings often overshadows the substantial body of evidence supporting their safety. Here are the key points:
- Mercury Release: The amount of mercury vapor released from dental amalgam during normal chewing and teeth grinding is extremely low and not harmful.
- Health Monitoring: Studies have shown that the mercury levels in people with amalgam fillings are similar to those in people without them and are well below toxic thresholds.
- Regulatory Stance: Health authorities globally have reviewed the evidence and concluded that dental amalgam is safe for the vast majority of people. Only certain groups, such as pregnant women and those with specific allergies to mercury, are advised to avoid amalgam fillings as a precaution.
- Long-Term Data: Longitudinal studies show no link between amalgam fillings and diseases such as Alzheimer’s, multiple sclerosis, or kidney disease.
At the end of the day, patients have the right to make informed decisions about their dental care. Dentists should provide information on all available restorative materials, including their benefits and potential risks. Understanding the evidence behind the safety of dental amalgam can help patients make informed choices without unnecessary fear.
Disclaimer
The contents of this website, such as text, graphics, images, and other material are for informational purposes only and are not intended to be substituted for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Nothing on this website constitutes the practice of medicine, law or any other regulated profession.
No two mouths are the same, and each oral situation is unique. As such, it isn’t possible to give comprehensive advice or diagnose oral conditions based on articles alone. The best way to ensure you’re getting the best dental care possible is to visit a dentist in person for an examination and consultation.
SAVE TIME AND MONEY AT ANY DENTIST
Less dental work is healthier for you. Learn what you can do to minimize the cost of dental procedures and avoid the dentist altogether!
English